SGC Gold Label: Its History, Rarity, and vs. BGS 10 Pristine

Affiliate Disclosure: When you click links at Only Greats & make a purchase, we may earn a commission. As a free site, we join affiliates like eBay & Amazon to help offset our costs. THANK YOU for your support!

Last Updated On: September 25th, 2023

What a year 1998 was here in the States. Harrison Ford was named People Mag’s Sexiest Man Alive, Seinfeld called it quits, and, least not of all, the author of this post was born. 

But more relevant for our discussion here, 1998 saw a revolution in sports card grading. In July, an upstart card grading service out of New Jersey called Sportscard Guaranty (SGC) was born. 

Over two decades later, SGC is now one of the “big three” grading companies in the hobby. In this post, we’re going to talk about one specific element of SGC’s story: the SGC gold label. We’ll dive into what it is, how it fits in SGC’s original and revamped grading scales, its rarity, and value comparison to other top-end graded cards from BGS and PSA. 

Let’s discuss!

Overview of SGC Grading

We can’t tell the story of SGC grading or the SGC gold label without setting the stage for its arrival into the hobby. 

In the summer of ‘98, a home run bonanza by (now infamous) Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa whipped baseball fans into a frenzy by beating Roger Maris’ single-season record for homers. Naturally, the excitement and attention carried over to the hobby, with fans clamoring to get their hands on rookie cards featuring the two surefire Hall of Famers.

But more than that, there was suddenly an intense interest in getting cards graded. At that point, PSA essentially held a monopoly on the hobby; BGS wouldn’t open its doors until 1999. And up until 1998, PSA had only graded around a million cards since its founding in 1991. From then on, however, PSA has graded at least one million cards per year.

Interested in more Sports Cards content? Subscribe to the blog! (opt out anytime)

Sensing an opening in the hobby, SGC was born. In yet another example of the grading surge, SGC was forced to expand rapidly; going from three graders to 20 in a matter of months.

Today, SGC is counted among the three industry leaders, along with BGS and PSA. While PSA still grades far and away the highest number of cards per year, 2022 saw nearly 988,000 passed through SGC’s inspectors. But since the beginning, SGC has done things a tad bit differently. That includes the original grading scale, which might look a bit funny to the modern collector.

SGC’s Grading Scale

SGC has relied on two different grading scales in its history. For the first 20 years of the company’s existence, SGC utilized a 10-100 scale before adjusting to a 1-10 (including half-grades) in 2018. But the company actually has two different “10” grading categories– a 10 “Pristine” and a 10 “Gem Mint,” with the former being far rarer than the latter. 

For comparison’s sake, BGS operates on a similar scale, but its 9.5 is a Gem Mint, while the 10 is reserved for Pristine condition cards. In addition, BGS offers sub-grading, so collectors get a sense of where their overall grade comes from. Finally, beginning in 2014, BGS began a “Black Label” for cards that earned a perfect 10 in every subgraded category.  

On the other hand, PSA is a standard 1-10 scale, with no subgrades offered. In addition, PSA does not grade any cards as “Pristine”; its 10 Gem Mint is the highest graded condition a card can receive.

Original Grading Scale Numbered to 100

Let’s have a closer look at SGC’s original 10-100 grading scale, starting with Gem Mint cards which score just shy of 100 perfect points.

SGC 98 Gem Mint

Before 2018, SGC’s Gem Mint condition was reserved for cards earning a 98 grade. In addition, this era featured a different SGC label altogether – notice the green labeling and dated font.

A card with a 96 grade was considered Mint, while an 88 was considered Near Mint.

SGC 100 Pristine Label and Its Design

But for the best of the best, SGC offered 100 grades. These cards were christened as Pristine and, initially, were not given any special designation on the label, as demonstrated by the Allen Iverson card below (turns out his handles aren’t the only thing immaculate in that portrait). 

In 2017, however, things started changing. SGC introduced a Gold Label for its Pristine cards, and, true to its word, SGC added a gold bordering to its Pristine cards. At this point, SGC was still using its green label for any non-100 graded cards. 

But that was about to change, as was the frequency with which SGC cards featured triple digits. 

Current Grading Scale Numbered to 10

Just one year after announcing its Gold Label, SGC switched up its grading, reforming to a “more standardized” 1-10 scale in 2018. 

But here’s where it gets a bit confusing: the company didn’t dispense with its Pristine label. Instead, SGC reserved the Pristine for a select few cards that are graded as “virtually flawless.” SGC also maintained its Gem Mint line, but rather than, you know, make like BGS and reserve Gem Mint for 9.5, they made 9.5 the grade for Mint+ cards. 

So then, what happened to Gem Mint?

SGC 10 Gem Mint

Yes, Gem Mint is also denoted with a 10 grade by SGC. It’s maddeningly puzzling for newcomers to the hobby, but this figure replaced the old 98, which was the original designation for Gem Mint cards on SGC’s 10-100 scale. 

According to SGC, Gem Mint cards are those that have:

55/45 or better centering, sharp focus, four sharp corners*, free of stains, no breaks in surface gloss, no print or refractor lines, and no visible wear. A slight print spot visible under close scrutiny is allowable if it does not detract from the aesthetics of the card.

SGC also moved from its original green labeling to its now familiar black labeling (also referred to a tux or tuxedo-look) non-Pristine cards, a wise choice that SGC says “complimented our holder” better.

SGC 10 Pristine Gold Label and Its Design

We already spoiled this surprise, but SGC maintained its Pristine condition and Gold Label under its new grading system, but it too is designated with a 10 grade. 

This is why paying attention to labeling is important when considering an SGC purchase. While you can get away with reading the number alone for a brand like PSA, you cannot do the same with SGC. Unfortunately, SGC’s label doesn’t exactly flash the grade quality in big bold letters – a new design in 2018 now features the condition abbreviated in a hexagon next to the number. So, you know, get out your readers if you’re trying to buy a card online. 

The 10 Pristine replaced the 100 grade in the old system, and the SGC Gold Label remained, even after the switch. SGC Gold Label cards are reserved for:

[a] “virtually flawless” card. 50/50 centering, crisp focus, four sharp corners, free of stains, no breaks in surface gloss, no print or refractor lines, and no visible wear under magnification.

In addition to switching the grading system, SGC altered its labeling in 2018. Initially, the SGC Gold Label included a gold edge along the label’s top. But after 2018, it was extended around the entirety of the label. 

The company announced the switch with an Aaron Judge rookie card – I guess you can take the collector out of Jersey but not the Jersey out of the collector?

How Rare is the SGC Gold Label?

In the hobby (as well as, well, anything), scarcity is everything. And SGC Gold Label cards are exceptionally rare. Here’s the breakdown of Pristine grades from a few notable sets in SGC’s pop report database.

SGC Pristine Pop Counts for Popular Sets

The following sets were selected not only for their popularity, but also for their higher population counts to give us a good sample size to work with. The figures represented below are from September, 2023.

2003-04 Topps Chrome Basketball aka “The LeBron James Rookie Set”:

• Total Graded: 1,474
• SGC Gold Label: 5
• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.3%

1986-87 Fleer Basketball aka “The Michael Jordan Rookie Set”:

• Total Graded: 29,820
• SGC Gold Label: 8
• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.027%

1989 Upper Deck Baseball aka “The Junk Wax/Ken Griffey Set”:

• Total Graded: 18,049
• SGC Gold Label: 39
• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.21%

2012 Panini Prizm Basketball aka “The First Prizm Basketball Set”:

• Total Graded: 1,756
• SGC Gold Label: 3
• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.17%

As you can see, the odds of hitting an SGC Gold Label card are pretty small (less than half a percent), no matter the set.

Keep in mind, if you find an SGC 100 and wish to reholder it in an SGC Gold Label, the company will do so. Those are gold too, even if the card was graded before the creation of the Gold Label in 2017.

How Rare is SGC’s Gold Label Compared to BGS 10 Pristine?

While PSA caps out at Gem Mint 10, BGS offers its own Pristine 10 grade.

But that’s not all; BGS also has the BGS Black Label. Black Label cards are a step up even from the BGS Pristine 10 (even though the label still reads “Pristine”) and reserved for cards that earn a perfect 10 in each of the company’s four subgrades. A standard, non-Black Label 10 Pristine is for cards that receive three 10s and one 9.5 subgrade. And BGS Gem Mint is for cards graded at 9.5. 

But how do the SGC Gold Labels stack up against the BGS 10 Pristine? And the Black Label? Let’s use those same sets from above as a measuring stick between SGC and BGS’ pop reports.

SGC Pristine vs. BGS 10 for Popular Sets

The figures represented below are calculated from data pulled in September, 2023.

2003-04 Topps Chrome Basketball aka “The LeBron James Rookie Set”:

• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.3%
• Total BGS Cards Graded: 14,030
• BGS Black Label: 12
• BGS Black Label Rate: 0.085%
• BGS 10 Pristine: 180
• BGS 10 Pristine Rate: 1.3%

1986-87 Fleer Basketball aka “The Michael Jordan Rookie Set”:

• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.027%
• Total BGS Graded: 74,117
• BGS Black Label: 1
• BGS Black Label Rate: 0.0013%
• BGS 10 Pristine: 51
• BGS 10 Pristine Rate: 0.068%

1989 Upper Deck Baseball aka “The Junk Wax/Ken Griffey Set”:

• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.21%
• Total BGS Graded: 60,537
• BGS Black Label: 5
• BGS Black Label Rate: 0.0083%
• BGS 10 Pristine: 952
• BGS 10 Pristine Rate: 0.68%

2012 Panini Prizm Basketball aka “The First Prizm Basketball Set”:

• SGC Gold Label Rate: 0.17%
• Total BGS Graded: 10,220**
• BGS Black Label: 33
• BGS Black Label Rate: 0.32%
• BGS 10 Pristine: 486
• BGS 10 Pristine Rate: 4.75%

** BGS divvies its Prizm pop report up by individual parallels; the above sample is a combination of the Base and Prizm (Silver) card for that year. While Panini didn’t release a Silver Prizm until 2014, the “Prizm” line is generally considered the Silver equivalent for the 2012 and 2013 sets

As we can see, the Black Label is far rarer than the SGC Gold Label in most sets, except it is surprisingly more prevalent in 2012 Prizm basketball by almost a 2 to 1 ratio. That said, the SGC Gold Label owns the day when it comes to rarity as compared with BGS 10 Pristines.

SGC Gold Label Value Comparison

But let’s get to brass tacks, here. How does SGC Gold Label compare value-wise to the hobby’s other two highest-rated graders? Let’s compare using a few notable cards from different sports that have received grading in each category. Unless otherwise noted, the sales prices come directly from CardLadder, with an estimated value from CardLadder if the card hasn’t sold within the last 12 months.

And listen, this was a challenging task – remember how few Black Label and Gold Label cards there are out there? Only a fraction of those even hit the market. The table below is designed to give you a rough idea of how these valuations generally track across BGS, PSA, and SGC, even if the data is incomplete for some. Based on the available info, you can probably fill in the gaps. 

Even though the data may be incomplete for a few cards, we still see a few trends emerge. Unsurprisingly, the BGS Black Label tends to carry the highest value — roughly a 2 to 1 value over SGC gold labels for the three cards with recent sales. This is likely a function of scarcity, which we covered above.

The one estimated value from CardLadder that is perplexing is for the Black Label Sidney Crosby Young Guns rookie card. It would be a huge surprise if that card sold today for 50x the value of an SGC 10 pristine gold label.

Now looking at PSA, notice how they trail in each category. That makes perfect sense, though. While PSA grades the most cards in the hobby, it doesn’t have a roped-off section reserved for VIP flawless cards. Hitting its ceiling at Gem Mint, a PSA 10 isn’t meant to capture the same rarity and perfection as a BGS Black Label or SGC Gold Label. In fact, a crossover PSA 10 likely wouldn’t net a BGS 10 Pristine, though in some exceedingly rare cases it might. It makes you wonder — will PSA ever introduce a pristine-level grade?

Final Verdict

For those looking to find perfect cards, the SGC Gold Label is an excellent place to start. That said, the odds of hitting a raw card that will grade out as flawless are long. Like, Carolina Panthers to lift the Lombardi Trophy in February long. With a pristine rate of 0.3% or worse, even at SGC’s reduced pricing of $15/card it would mean one pristine gold label per 300 cards graded, or $4,500 in grading fees.

While PSA will likely hang on to the top grading spot for the foreseeable future, SGC is doing all it can to make itself competitive in the marketplace as an excellent grading brand with surging popularity.